About Scarlet Dental

Scarlet Dental provides each and every patient with superior quality dental care in a fun and friendly environment. We strive to go above and beyond for every patient. At Scarlet Dental, you’ll leave smiling!

Dr. Katie Vincer Sears

Dr. Vincer owns Scarlet Dental in both Pickerington and Zanesville. Dr. Vincer graduated from Saint Mary's of Notre Dame before graduating from The Ohio State University with her doctorate in dental surgery. She is an adjunct professor for The Ohio State University’s College of Dentistry, has served on multiple boards for Saint Mary's College, and has also served on several advisorary committees for both the American Dental Association and Ohio Dental Association. She has received the honors of American Dental Association's 10 Under 10 Award in 2022, which recognizes the top 10 dentists in all of the United States who have been practicing 10 years or less, as well as Columbus Business First's 40 Under 40 in 2017.

Her professional mission is to provide all patients, regardless of their socioeconomic status, with the highest quality of dentistry possible in a welcoming and beautiful office!

  • She has volunteered at the Maasai Dental Clinic in the Mara of Kenya in 2019 and 2017.
  • She volunteers regularly at the free extraction clinic at the Columbus Health Department.
  • She has held ADA’s Give Kids A Smile event in her office for the past ten years.
  • She visits schools and childcare centers educating kids on oral hygiene.
  • Her and her husband have chaired Cornerstone of Hope's annual gala for the past three years.
  • She has been a feature guest on podcasts such as 200 Proof Life, Momcast, MDIBs (Mommy Dentists in Business), and the American Dental Association.

Dr. Vincer and her husband, Scott, have three young kids: Scotty, Stella, and John. Dr. Vincer proudly resides in Pickerington. She enjoys traveling the world with her family, being an avid reader, and cheering on both the Irish and the Buckeyes!

Dr. James D Haldeman
Dr. James D. Haldeman

Dr. Haldeman began at Scarlet Dental in 2019. Prior to that he owned a private practice focused on cosmetic and restorative dentistry. The staff here has nick named him Dr. Wonderful. He truly has a passion for dentistry and it is easy to see in the way he cares for his patients and the staff. He is the king of corny Dad/Grandpa jokes. He does laugh at his own jokes and doesn’t care when people roll their eyes when he tells them.

He has 2 adult sons and is blessed with 4 grandchildren. He is fortunate to be able to spend a lot of time with them as they live locally.

Dr. Roach
Dr. Roach

Dr. Roach practices at both of the Scarlet Dental locations. Dr. Roach graduated from Miami University before graduating from Maurice H. Kornberg School of Dentistry at Temple University in Philadelphia, PA. Dr. Roach graduated Magna Cum Laude and was awarded the American College of Prosthodontists Award upon graduation for his dedication to improving and restoring patient’s smiles.

Dr. Roach and his wife live in Grove City, Ohio with their dog Phil. He enjoys woodworking, working out and traveling. He is a big Buckeye football fan and a hopeful Browns fan.

Contact Info

107 W. Columbus St.
Pickerington, Ohio 43147
Phone: 614-829-7703
3205 Broadvue Circle
Zanesville, OH 43701
Phone: 740-454-6705

Office Hours

Monday | 8:00am - 5:00pm
Tuesday | 8:00am - 5:00pm
Wednesday | 8:00am - 5:00pm
Thursday | 8:00am - 5:00pm
Friday | 8:00 am – 3:00 pm
Saturday | Closed
Sunday | Closed

Before & After